Benchmark your primary category against the map pack, not your own menu

Benchmark your primary category against the map pack, not your own menu

Written by

in

The verdict

Your primary category is not a description of your business. It is a bet on which search you want to compete in, and the right answer is already published: go and read the primary category of the three to five profiles currently winning the map pack for your service and your city. Most clinics pick theirs from a dropdown in ninety seconds and never look at what the competition chose.

Open a map pack for the service you sell in the town you sell it in. Three results. Each of those businesses has a primary category, and you can read it. That is the benchmark, and it takes about four minutes to collect.

Almost nobody does this. The category gets chosen once, during setup, by somebody scrolling a dropdown looking for the word that sounds most like the business.

Why the dropdown misleads you

Because it rewards accuracy and the field does not pay for accuracy. It pays for competitiveness.

Google asks you to use as few categories as possible to describe your overall core business from the provided list, and to select categories that complete the statement “this business IS a” rather than “this business HAS a”. That is good guidance for avoiding nonsense. It is not guidance about which of three legitimate options will put you in more searches, because Google is not going to tell you that.

So you have a field that materially affects how well your profile matches what someone is searching for, several defensible values, and no published guidance on choosing between them. That is exactly the situation where you look at what is already winning.

How to run the benchmark

Four minutes, once

  • Search your money term, in your town, from your town. Location matters to what you see. If you are not physically there, the result is not the one your patients get.
  • Take the top three to five map results. Not the ads. Not the organic results underneath.
  • Record each one’s primary category. It is visible on the profile.
  • Count. If four of five share a category and you are not using it, that is the finding, and it is usually the whole audit’s biggest single item.
  • Repeat for your second and third money terms. They often disagree, and the disagreement tells you which business you are actually in.

When the benchmark and the truth disagree

Sometimes the winning category is one you could technically claim but should not.

I have refused categories for clients on exactly these grounds: a specialty the practitioner does not hold, a procedure the practice does not perform, a credential nobody on staff has. Google’s IS a test catches most of it. The rest is judgement, and the question to ask is not whether the category is arguable but whether the leads it brings will arrive wanting something you sell.

A category that generates calls you have to turn down is worse than a slightly less competitive one that does not. You pay for those calls in staff time and you never see the cost in a dashboard.

The case where the benchmark has no answer

Occasionally your largest service has no category at all. Not a badly named one. None exists in the list.

When that happens the benchmark still works, it just answers a different question. It tells you which of the available categories the market has settled on for businesses like yours, and the demand your category cannot express has to be captured somewhere else: in the services list, in the profile description, and in the pages on your own site. I have written that case up in full at the post about clinic markup and types that do not exist, because the same gap shows up in structured data.

Doing it in the right order

This is the first of eight checks I run on a profile, and it is first because it moves more than the other seven combined. The full order and why it is the order covers the rest, but if you only ever do one thing to a Business Profile, this is the one.

The short version

  1. The right category is already published. Read what the map pack leaders are using.
  2. Four minutes, once. Top three to five results, record the primary category, count.
  3. The field rewards competitiveness, not accuracy. The dropdown rewards accuracy, which is why it misleads.
  4. Search from your town. Results you see somewhere else are not the ones patients get.
  5. Refuse a category that brings wrong-fit calls, even if you could argue for it.
  6. Run it for your top three terms. Where they disagree, you learn which business you are in.
  7. Do this before anything else on the profile.

If a site should be ranking and it isn’t, that’s the work I do. SEO for chiropractors covers where the effort belongs in a practice, and local SEO is where the profile and the pages get treated as one job.

Headshot of Mehul Dedhia, SEO consultant

Written by Mehul Dedhia

I’ve been doing SEO for about fifteen years. Most of my work isn’t building new websites. It’s figuring out why sites that should rank don’t. Local businesses, ecommerce and Shopify brands, affiliate sites, small brands and enterprise. If a site is stuck or has lost rankings, that’s usually where I come in.

Connect with me on LinkedIn